Skip to main content
Home
Snurblog — Axel Bruns

Main navigation

  • Home
  • Information
  • Blog
  • Research
  • Publications
  • Presentations
  • Press
  • Creative
  • Search Site

Challenges of Universal Broadband Access in the U.S.

Snurb — Friday 14 October 2011 02:32
Politics | Internet Technologies | AoIR 2011 |

Seattle.
The next speaker in this session at AoIR 2011 is Susan Kretchmer, whose focus is on the continuing digital divide. The U.S. ranks surprisingly lowly on broadband Internet adoption; some 14 million Americans do not have access to broadband, and 100 million could have access but don’t use it because they can’t afford it or don’t realise the advantages. Rates are especially low amongst the most disadvantaged groups.

This is being addressed through the development of a National Broadband Plan by the FCC, under instructions by the Obama administration. This envisages the U.S. as a 21st century information society, realising the social and economic benefits of broadband access. This builds on the language of a social contract for the development of greater access. Susan argues that this project must serve the public interest, and needs a clear nuanced understanding of the shifting demographics of diversity, and the ability to harness the lessons of past attempts and failures to achieve universal access.

Policy outcomes that support diversity have yet to be employed; the five decade-long failure to even achieve universal telephone access doesn’t bode well for broadband access policies – better universal access policies are required here. Some 10% or more of households consistently tend to lack access, and provide a significant barrier to achieving universal access. There are substantial variations related to age, race, ethnicity, and other socioeconomic and demographic differences; there are also important gaps between urban and rural populations.

Many official data sources may underestimate or overlook crucial realities of access gaps, in fact; for example, there are a substantial number of households excluded from the telephone network, or unable to connect to it consistently, for a variety of reasons. Non-payment is one important factor in this; few organisations are collecting data on such barriers to access. Vermont, for example, appears to have a high level of telephone penetration, but telephone disconnection rates are also comparatively high, so access remains far from universal.

Susan’s study examined households which remained without telephone access for more than 24 hours (but she’s skipping through her data very quickly, so it’s hard to follow the detail); phone disconnections appear to be related to the need to prioritise other payments in economically stressed households, for example. Of course it’s also important to recognise that there is a gradual shift from household-based (landline) to individual (mobile) telephone access in many cases, which adds further complexities.

There’s a need to move beyond the idea of saturation here, and to mobilise the four Cs of access – connectivity, but also capability (faster networks), content (free and diverse), and context (understanding local needs and opportunities). Successful access policies depend on implementation and recognition of specificities on the ground.

  • 4317 views
INFORMATION
BLOG
RESEARCH
PUBLICATIONS
PRESENTATIONS
PRESS
CREATIVE

Recent Work

Presentations and Talks

Beyond Interaction Networks: An Introduction to Practice Mapping (ACSPRI 2024)

» more

Books, Papers, Articles

Untangling the Furball: A Practice Mapping Approach to the Analysis of Multimodal Interactions in Social Networks (Social Media + Society)

» more

Opinion and Press

Inside the Moral Panic at Australia's 'First of Its Kind' Summit about Kids on Social Media (Crikey)

» more

Creative Work

Brightest before Dawn (CD, 2011)

» more

Lecture Series


Gatewatching and News Curation: The Lecture Series

Bluesky profile

Mastodon profile

Queensland University of Technology (QUT) profile

Google Scholar profile

Mixcloud profile

[Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 Licence]

Except where otherwise noted, this work is licensed under a Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 Licence.